Come to Kinross - At The Heart of It All

Clerk Marvin Besteman gets a 100% raise

by Dorothy Johnson

A week after he returned from a trip to the Bahamas, the Board voted to raise the Clerk's salary 100% to $13,000.00. The following are points of interest regarding this situation which I will list and let you come to your own conclusion. 

  • The Clerk is mad because he wanted $15,000 or 120% raise.
  • The Bahamas trip is a big perk Marvin receives as a result of being on the Board for an Insurance organization called the Michigan Township Participating Plan.
  • The Michigan Township Participating Plan is the Kinross Townships Liability Insurance Company.
  • When asked about his activities with Michigan Township Participating Plan Marvin admitted that yes he had spent 5 days in the Bahamas with all expenses paid by the Michigan Township Participating Plan but insisted it had nothing to do with the Michigan Township Association.
  • It just so happens that the Michigan Township Participating Plan holds a $10,000 “Presidents seat” with the MTA so he wasn't quite truthful about that either.
  • When asked further questions by Herman Calkins Marvin said that he needed to go to this meeting “because we have two lawsuits against us”.
  • Marvin made it sound like they went to the Bahamas to discuss the Kinross Township lawsuits.
  • Since this is a Michigan organization and we all know that Michigan is in an economic slump, why did the Michigan Township Participating Plan Board travel to the Bahamas to have their meeting and not give the business to a Michigan convention center.
  • We pay monthly premium payments to the Michigan Township Participating Plan
  • Why would we consider continuing to do business with a company that wastes money in the Bahamas instead of spending it in Michigan?
  • Is Marvin’s position on the Board of Directors with the Michigan Township Participating Plan in conflict with his Township Board seat given that we contract with the Michigan Township Participating Plan for services and he has voted on that contract?
  • Marvin has admitted that the Township is currently being sued by two different parties. How can he act objectively on the two suits when he is a Board member for the Michigan Township Participating Plan? They have a vested financial interest in the outcome of the lawsuits which Marvin would vote on. How can he vote or act objectively in these matters. Should he not abstain from any further Township Board votes or actions on the lawsuits? Is this not a conflict of interests since he is on a Board that represents many other Townships.
  • According to The Michigan Township Participating Plan Marvin is the Convention and Annual meeting committee Chair
  • According to The Michigan Township Participating Plan members of the MTPP Board have traveled on similar trips to England and Germany. Since Marvin has been a MTPP director for over 10 years has he also enjoyed these perk trips as well. Remember the Township pays monthly premiums to the MTPP. Sounds like he has been living it up at the taxpayer expense.
  • The Michigan Township Participating Plan is administered by the Kenrick Corporation who's Michigan agent is the Burnham & FlowerAgency, Inc. The Kenrick Corporation is a Subsidiary of HCC Insurance Holdings, Inc..These are the agencies' that treat Marvin Besteman to fancy dinners when he and crony Oberle travel to the MTA annual conferences. This is illegal. You can not give gifts of any kind to elected officials in exchange for support of future contracts. Each year at the MTA annual convention the Par Plan hosts perk parties such as bringing an indoor fair complete with rides and cotton candy for the Township officials to enjoy. These activities add up to noting more that pandering to elected officials for their continued vote to contract with them for services. If this is not illegal it should be.

One of the lawsuits Marvin mentioned is Joe Paczkowski’s lawsuit against the Township for violating his Veteran Preference rights when they “eliminated” his position(s) with the Township. Federal law designates all Veterans to have earned the right to be “just cause” employees. “Just cause” means that the employer has to show good reason to eliminate a Veteran from their position. Joe was not given any reason and was denied a hearing to review their reasons for eliminating his position(s) all of which is a violation of Federal law. Marvin voted to eliminate Joe’s position and now has activated the Michigan Township Participating Plans attorneys to try to assassinate Joe’s character rather that doing the right thing and uphold Federal and State law like Board members Dan Mitchell and Fred McClendon have requested. Instead the Michigan Township Participating Plans job now is to discredit Joe and cheat him out of his rights. Is it now a conflict for Marvin to have any input on Joe's lawsuit since Marvin is the recipient of big time perks from the Michigan Township Participating Plan who have a vested financial interest in the Townships illegal behavior?

In other Township action at the May 19th Board meeting the Board was pressed by Herman Calkins to take action on Dan Mitchell’s push to eliminate the Boards health insurance. Despite attempts by Marvin Besteman to derail the action, Dan put together a motion in the last few minutes of the meeting to eliminate the Insurance with Dan Mitchell, Fred McClendon, and Ed Dewitt voting for it and Clerk Besteman and Oberle voting against. The motion passed. Even though the insurance has now been taken away we must be vigilant to monitor the Board to make sure they don’t resend the resolution and get the Health Insurance back. Herman Calkins stated “this meeting has been both historical and hysterical and without Paczkowski’s video documentation of the Boards actions we may have never gotten this passed”.

New Salaries:

Supervisor - $25,000, no health Insurance, Clerk - $13,000, no health insurance, Treasurer - $13,000, no health insurance, Trustees - $2,500 / $50 per meeting / $30 per committee meeting /, no health insurance

All Board members will be allowed to buy their health insurance through the Townships group health policy.